Justiceforhaleigh's Blog

Opinions and observations about the case

Big Announcement! August 23, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 2:41 pm

Justice for Haleigh has a new home at this link

http://justiceforhaleigh.afterhoursfriends.com/

 

After considering AfterHoursFriends invitation to move the blog to be hosted at their website, I have made the decision to do so.   Many readers have asked for a forum and through this host, you will be able to have discussion at After Hours Friends Hearts for Haleigh Forum.  You will find the link at the new blog.

 

Comments will continue to be moderated below articles but please take advantage of Haleigh’s forum as well.

 

Thank you, Hobbit for your generous invitation.  I look forward to settling into my new home.

 

A Birthday Poem

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 6:50 am

Written by Crystal for Haleigh’s Birthday.

Posted with permission.

 

HAPPY BIRTHDAY HALEIGHMommy

I can feel your soft fingers fold into my hand 

as I hear you say “Mommy!”

This precious memory is more than I can stand.

I can see your face glowing with innocence and love.

Your curls lay soft against your face, as your memory lays soft on my heart. 

Where are you HaLeigh I must demand!

I can see your eyes filled with wonder they give out a bright spark. 

Why can’t someone find you?

Who knows ? Will they set you free?

HaLeigh the love you have given me would bring most moms to their knees.

And because of your love I now bend on my knees to ask…..

“God Please Bring My daughter Home To Me”. 

A million times I’ve needed you a million times I’ve cried.

If I was there …. could I have saved you?

For you I would have died.

I wish I could snuggle near you and whisper you name.

“HaLeigh precious HaLeigh..I love you !”

“I’m right here at your side.”

So on this 6th birthday I promise you!

I’ll dip into my well of faith, new strength to find…

I’ll look the whole world over

UNTIL, MY HALEIGH, I FIND!.

  
  
Your Mommy,
Crystal

from

 

Child Support Disbursements August 22, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 6:13 pm

Below is a copy of the child support disbursement document for child support payments from Crystal Sheffield to Ron Cummings.

 

 

childsupport0001[1]

 

Follow this link to view full size   http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/3575/childsupport00011.jpg

This document shows that Ron Cummings has received over $13,000 in child support payments since May 1, 2009, almost $9,000 of which was received since July 1, 2009.

 

Child support is not in arrears as of  today, August 22, 2009.

 

First and foremost, this information, printed directly from the Florida Department of Revenue website should clarify that Ron Cummings has received all monies due to him through August 1, 2009.   

 

Second, it raises some questions about Ron Cummings’ criminal case.

According to the docket, posted below, Ron has claimed he is insolvent and has asked for a public defender for his arrest on August 6.

CRIMINAL

 

How can Cummings be insolvent when he has received such a large sum of money and appears to be using it to pay for the services of another attorney in his ongoing civil/family court case?

 

CIVIL DOCKET

 

If anyone knows what criteria qualify a person for a public defender please share.

 

Follow up to this morning’s article August 21, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 3:25 pm

Since we know Tim Miller is bringing his group back to Putnam County in 6-8 weeks to search for Haleigh, I believe it is imperative that we strongly encourage TES to search the area around PDM Bridge.

 

Texas Equusearch can be contacted online at this link

http://texasequusearch.org/contact-tes/

 

Tim Miller can be contacted directly via e mail at this address:

tim.miller@texasequusearch.org

 

TES Attorney, Mark NeJame can be e mailed at this address:

Attorney@NeJameLaw.com

 

I urge anyone and everyone to contact these men to request searches of the PDM grounds and surrounding area.   Feel free to use the information from this morning’s entry in your messages.

 

Please share any responses received here in the comments section.

 

PDM Bridge

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 5:52 am

This entry is written by a man who I admire tremendously.  Not only for his kindness, but also for the methodical approach he uses when scrutinizing this case.   It concerns PDM Bridge and the property surrounding it, and addresses the reason that area warrants an intensive search as soon as possible.

 

Thank you, Papa for sharing your thoughts as well as your permission for your words to appear here.

 

PDM

 

I’m going to throw something out for thought. What if RC had a very specific reason to show up at work?

I have darkened the north part of the PDM property on this map to illustrate better the points below.

 

-What if you learned that RC’s job with PDM was as a yard helper around the building in the northern half of the property?

-What if you learned that his primary job function was driving a forklift?

-What if you learned that this area is pitch black dark at night with no lighting?

-What if you learned that the yard has few security cameras with none in the northern portion?

-What if you learned that there was only one security guard on the property who didn’t leave the guard shack located at the front entrance below the south parking lot?

-What if you learned that more than one employee of PDM has called the LE tip line requesting a search of the woods/swamp on the northern half of this property?

-Would you be curious why a search by LE never happened, even though they went a hundred miles away and dug up dead horse bones?

 

Misty in the Limelight August 19, 2009

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 4:38 pm

This week has brought a great deal of negative attention to Misty Croslin.  She and her story have been dissected and criticized in local and national media.  People are calling on Misty to tell the truth about the events of the evening Haleigh disappeared.

 

For example, Nancy Grace featured the Haleigh case on her show last night.  Several items of interest.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0908/18/ng.01.html

Nancy Grace and her guests discuss the case and Misty’s inconsistencies;

 

T.J. HART, WSKY 97.3 FM (via telephone): It certainly is. This certainly narrows down the field of suspects from everyone to someone. And as you remember, everyone was a suspect when this began, and all the way up until the last couple of hours, too. Still, the one thing you`ve got, Ronald and Crystal no longer suspects. But Misty`s story, still inconsistent, as it was from day one. And I can tell you, some of that physical evidence that`s not jibing up with the story is the fact that on that back door, there`s no sign of forced entrance whatsoever.

GRACE: Wait a minute, T.J. We knew that from the get-go, that there wasn`t a sign of forced entry. Nobody had taken a device and forced the lock open on that back door. We knew that at the beginning.

HART: That`s true, but it was taken in for further investigation, and it has gone through still some more forensics. And definitively — yes, we did know that at the beginning, but definitively no forced entry. And that, of course, does lead officials to believe that once again, right where they stated, this is not a stranger.

 

MARC KLAAS, KLAAS KIDS FOUNDATION: … But Misty, who was the last person to see the little girl, whose story continually shifts and who statistics point right to, has not been able to clear herself.

I think that what she needs to do is to tell the truth. And the way to do that is not to bring a lawyer and put her between the truth and finding that little girl.

 

GRACE: You know what`s interesting to you, Dr. Lillian Glass, psychologist, body language expert, author of “I Know What You`re Thinking” — Lillian, do you notice that she repeatedly refers to “that little girl.” Now…

LILLIAN GLASS, PSYCHOLOGIST: Exactly!

GRACE: … I don`t think in the nearly two years I`ve had the twins, I`ve ever referred to them in that manner. I don`t know what that means. I`m just a lawyer. What does it mean?

GLASS: She`s detaching. And when you look at her body language, she says it all. She`s crying these crocodile or alligator tears. You`re seeing her with a very flat affect. You`re seeing her shoulders shrugging, looking away. She has a lot of tells that show deception.

 

GRACE: Interesting. You know, you`re bringing something up and you`re jogging my memory, Donna in Massachusetts. Why would you put the children to sleep, then go wash the blankets that you`re going to put over them? Well, why would you do that? Why wouldn`t you put a different blanket over them and wash the others?

DET. LT. STEVEN ROGERS, NUTLEY, NJ, POLICE DEPARTMENT: Well, it doesn`t. And I can tell you, the police have examined every inch of that home, and there`s a lot of evidence there that will now come out.

HART: That just sounds a little odd. At that time in February in Florida, it does — and especially at that area, it does get a little cool at night. But still, when you put your children to bed, you put them to bed, ready for bed, with a blanket on them.

 GRACE: Well, T.J., they might as well take out an ad on 3rd Avenue that says Misty Croslin was not at home at the time of the kidnapping. Because if they, the police, are asking the public.

HART: That`s right.

GRACE: Hey, did any of you see the stepmother the night she went missing, the night she says she`s at home washing the blankets and putting them to bed at 8:00? I mean.

HART: That would explain making up some of these stories on the fly, allegedly, in the way of putting together a time line.

GRACE: And let`s go back to the lawyers. Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi in New York, Raymond Giudice, Atlanta, Hugo Rodriguez, Miami.

Raymond, this means that if we`re interpreting what the police are saying correctly, this just puts it out there. Here`s a theory. And again, Misty Croslin is not a suspect. That if they are asking, “where is she?”

RAY GIUDICE, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Right.

GRACE: That night. That suggests that everything she said was false. She was not at home. She did not put them to bed at 8:00. She did not put a blanket on them. She didn`t wake up to go to the bathroom and notice the child was missing.

And if you believe that somebody else took the child, you would have to believe in the window, the hours that she`s gone, somebody detected she was gone and knew how to get into the back door and not make a mark on the door and take the child.

Now how likely is it, Raymond Giudice, that all those factors fit together?

GIUDICE: Right. I really believe law enforcement is trying to smoke her out. There`s been no action on this case in six months. And they`re trying to get a reaction from her one way or another. Either a defensive statement or does she go hire counsel and clam up and they interpret that as an indication that as law enforcement would believe she has something to hide.

GRACE: Let`s get a try to get a straight answer out of Nicolazzi. What about it Anna-Sigga? Do you believe — I mean does it make sense in your practice of law that all of these factors would fall together and the stars would align, that she happens to be gone and during those hours that she`s gone this unknown phantom person was watching the home and sneaks in with no forcible entry and takes a child?

ANNA-SIGGA NICOLAZZI, PROSECUTOR: Nancy, your incredulous way that you just went through that is my answer. This would be a miraculous coincidence. That makes no sense. The same woman who is telling different stories, who is evasive, who is not answering the police questions about the time line.

At the same time a stranger comes in and abducts not both children but one with no trace? And a door that we saw she said was open but we know shuts? There`s just too many coincidences that point to her lying. And I think that the police are now trying a different tact to get to the bottom, to get some real answers from her.

 

GRACE: Melody in Ohio, how I wish, how I have wished it was that easy. Let me go back to Detective Lieutenant Steven Rogers, Nutley, New Jersey Police Department. Former fed with the FBI.

Detective, what can they do?

DET. LT. STEVE ROGERS, NUTLEY, NEW JERSEY, POLICE DEPARTMENT: Nancy, you hit the nail on the head. It`s not that easy. But I`ve got to tell you, I believe — and I`m sure, on your show in the past, from day one, the police had some indication, some belief, that she had something to do with this. That`s ground zero. It started there. It`s going to end there.

 

In spite of the statement from police, the comments from various experts and the media coverage, it appears that the Cummings/Neves/Sykes family has decided to protect and defend Misty.

 

Haleigh’s grandmother, Teresa Neves was interviewed by Jacksonville.com on Monday.  Her response to the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office press release;   http://jacksonville.com/news/metro/crime/2009-08-17/story/focus_is_narrowing_in_haleighs_disappearance_police_say

 

Ronald Cummings’ mother said she does not believe her daughter-in-law has misled investigators. Misty Croslin has a seventh-grade education, Teresa Neves said and should not be able to fool interrogators that have included FBI agents.

“She feels they are not being fair to her,” Neves said Monday.

 

So Haleigh’s grandmother  refutes the words of Lt. Greenwood simply because Misty is not educated beyond the seventh grade. 

 

NEWSFLASH Teresa Neves;  how can she fool anybody when she and your son will not talk with investigators?    Ms. Neves, why is it that I, a total and complete stranger, someone who has never met your granddaughter see the ignorance of your statement about what is fair to Misty yet you have the audacity to repeat such a statement to the media?  What about Haleigh?  Remember her?   She’s your granddaughter who has been missing for six months.   The little girl that was LOST whilst Misty was caring for her.  She is the only person out of all of you who deserves the consideration of fairness. 

 

And Sykes on Nancy Grace last night:

 

GRACE: Got it. To Annette Sykes, the great-grandmother of little Haleigh, joining us from Weelaka, Florida. Ms. Sykes, what do you make of police saying that the girlfriend/baby-sitter has not given them full answers?

SYKES: Nancy, I`m not real sure about that. I`m not exactly sure what Misty has said to them because I`ve never really been told. And I`m not sure what their timeline or whatever it is they are — you know, I`m not aware of all of the exact things, you know? So I don`t know — you know, I don`t know.

 

Are we really expected to believe that Annette Sykes, Haleigh’s great grandmother and Ronald’s grandmother; the person with whom Ron and Misty have been residing for almost half a year-  has never asked Misty what happened the night her own great granddaughter disappeared? 

 

Preposterous?    I believe it is.  

 

If I found myself in Mrs. Sykes’ shoes, you better believe that I would relentlessy question the person who lost a child until I understood every hour, every second, every moment of the evening that child disappeared.

 

The only reason I could imagine not asking would be if I either already knew or were afraid of the answers.

 

Misty’s response to the renewed and very public focus on her?      The woman-child who only five months ago proclaimed “Lawyers are for guilty people, I have nothing to hide,”  has hired an attorney.   According to the Palatka Daily News 

(http://www.palatkadailynews.com/articles/2009/08/19/news/news01.txt)

 

Misty’s attorney Robert Fields said

Fields said he and Croslin-Cummings would work with investigators if needed.

“I don’t know where it’s going to go,” Fields said. “I think at this point I am going to have to be involved to some degree.”

 

Mr. Fields, I beg you.  Get Misty to talk.   

 

Update to Family Court Docket

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 3:44 pm

 

The motion initiated by Crystal last week has now been set for a hearing according to activity on the docket this week.   Crystal’s demand that her son Ronald Jr. receive counseling has obviously been met with resistance from Ronald since it is now going before a judge.

 

Also of interest is the entry from 8/17-  Notice of Non-representation from Jerry Snider.  Could it be that Ronald’s now former attorney understands that Ron Jr. desperately needs counseling and refuses to be a party to Ronald’s resistance?   The timing leads me to believe this may be the case.

 

I find it impossible to fathom that any family court judge would find it acceptable to refuse professional mental health counseling for a little boy who’s sister was allegedly kidnapped from the room in which he was sleeping.   I also find it impossible to imagine that any attorney would advise or support their client’s resistance to such help to a child who needs it so badly.

 

So the question I have is why would Ron Cummings resist getting help for his son?  What is he afraid of?  What does Ronald Jr. have tucked away in his mind that needs to remain hidden?  What could be more important than ensuring the mental health of your child?  Self preservation?  Fear of the truth being disclosed?

 

Putnam County Sheriff’s Office Press Release

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 1:01 pm

Haleigh Cummings’ 6th Birthday Observed

2009-8-17 by: Lt. Johnny Greenwood
Today marks Haleigh Cummings’ sixth birthday, and a little over six months into the investigation of her disappearance. Sheriff Hardy’s interest in the public’s desire to bring Haleigh home, have led him to release the following update on the investigation.

Investigators from the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, and investigators from agencies throughout Florida have invested thousands of man-hours into the investigation thus far.

 

Here are some of the facts:
We have received in excess of 4,000 leads, all of which have been followed up.
We have conducted 138 formal interviews and several hundred informal interviews with potential witnesses. DNA samples were collected from many of those interviewed and compared to evidence collected in the case.
FDLE processed the crime scene. Many items of potential evidentiary value were collected and sent to
 
FDLE’s crime lab for analysis (ie. for fingerprints and DNA). All of evidence has been examined and/or processed, but none of it has identified any suspect or additional leads as to who the suspect(s) may be.
We have searched thousands of acres, including all property west of Highway 17 near the Cummings residence.
We have had numerous underwater recovery and search teams search all of the water near the area of the disappearance.
Aviation assets have conducted several airborne searches.
K9 assets have searched the area on several occasions.
Volunteer civilian searchers on foot and horseback searched the wooded areas near the residence.

At this point, the evidence and investigatory effort has minimized the likelihood that Haleigh’s disappearance is the work of a stranger. There is no specific individual whom investigators have identified as a person of interest. The biological parents, Ronald Cummings and Crystal Sheffield, are not considered to be suspects in the case. Investigators believe that Misty Croslin-Cummings continues to hold important answers in the case. She has failed to provide any sort of detailed accounting of the hours during the late evening and early morning of Haleigh’s disappearance. Furthermore, physical evidence at the scene contradicts Misty’s sketchy account of her evening activities. Any citizen with direct knowledge of Misty’s activities during that evening or into the early morning is encouraged to report that information to the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office.

Sheriff Hardy realizes the importance of keeping the public involved in this case, and appreciates all of the leads that have been provided. Every lead that is provided is acted on by investigators. Sheriff Hardy cautions that because there are many who claim to be valid media outlets, that citizens should be careful not to fall into the trap of believing, or by accident spreading, the untrue and unreliable claims and assumptions of many bloggers who claim to be knowledgeable in the case. He also urges anyone that is assisting, or who wants to assist, to be cautious to stay within the bounds of their authority as they pursue their activities.

Sheriff Hardy wants to assure the public, but mainly Haleigh’s family, that we will continue to aggressively pursue this case and that we welcome the assistance of all Law Enforcement agencies or any other expert, including air, water, and ground searchers,  that can assist in bringing Haleigh home.

 

 

Finally we received official word from the authorities pertaining to the status of this case.  The key takeaways I find from this press release are as follows; (my thoughts & opinions on each point are in italics following each point)

  • Neither of Haleigh’s biological parents are considered suspects in her disappearance.  Such a relief to know that the authorities don’t think that the two people who are supposed to love this child more than anyone else are responsible for the current sad state of affairs. 
  • The authorities do not believe this was a stranger abduction. This clarifies and debunks the oft shared theory that a sex offender or random stranger is responsible for Haleigh’s disappearance.  It was somebody close to Haleigh.
  • Misty Croslin-Cummings continues to be the key to learning what happened to Haleigh.  Greenwood stopped short of calling Misty a suspect, but in my opinion, he made it clear that at the very least she is a person of interest who is witholding information of interest. Not a surprise, but nice to see that the PCSO recognizes stonewalling.
  • Physical evidence at the home supports the theory that Misty is not being honest with regard to her actions or activities that evening.  I have heard rumors since shortly after Haleigh’s disappearance that Misty was not being honest and that physical evidence proved that.  I am pleased this has been officially confirmed.
  • The PCSO implores anyone with information about Misty’s activities or whereabouts the evening/early morning hours of February 9/10 to please come forward.   I wish Greenwood had offered some kind of immunity for prosecution pertaining to the activities of anyone who can shed light on where Misty was and what she was doing that night.
  • The PCSO cautions the public about believing internet bloggers posing as reporters.   This has been an ongoing problem since the beginning.  Many people claim to have information and have disseminated rumors as truth.  Not only forum members, but also moderators, bloggers, and people who comment below articles on various news websites.  I have never claimed to be a reporter or media professional.  This blog clearly states that I am simply sharing my opinions and observations on this case.   I urge everyone not to believe anything you read online that is authored by an internet “handle” and instead focus on real reporters who are willing to share their names, credentials and valid associations with reputable media outlets.  If some random internet person claims to have spoken to law enforcement yet no official statement has been made, you can be fairly certain that the information being shared is neither true nor accurate.

 

My Experience at Haleigh’s Closet

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 12:31 pm

From a friend who would prefer to remain anonymous.

 

I spent most of the day at Riverfront Park on Saturday, August 15.  I arrived early enough to assist the family with setting up tents, decorating, and getting organized.  Crystal, Marie, and several other family members & friends, old and young were there to support the family and the event.

 

The turnout was fair.  Many generous internet friends from out of town sent school supplies to Marie’s home so we started out with several boxes before the event was opened.  Several generous donors stopped at the park throughout the day to bring their donations of school supplies.  One special visitor drove all the way from Tampa to deliver a gigantic rubbermaid container loaded with at least 40 lbs of school supplies. 

 

The most important goal……….getting Haleighs name and face in the media was accomplished.  Several media outlets visited throughout the day to take pictures, video, and conduct interviews with the family.

 

The first two media vans arrived around 12:00 noon.  Within 60 seconds of their arrival, Ron, Misty, Annette, and Teresa pulled into the park with Butterbean/Ron Jr. in tow.  They brought backpacks loaded with school supplies, which they dropped on the table.  Butterbean jumped out of the car and immediately ran to his mother.  He did not leave her side until he got back into the car with his father to leave.

 

After the Cummings dropped their school supplies, they proceeded to post signs advertising their own event, a balloon release around the perimeter of the park.   They spoke with the media as well.  After about 30-40 minutes it looked like it was going to rain.  The two media vans left and the Cummings left right after them.

 

Throughout the time the Cummings were at the park, an unmarked Palatka PD vehicle remained in the parking lot.  When they left, so did the police vehicle.

 

The school arrived around 4:30 to collect the donated supplies.  They were thankful and appreciative of the efforts of the family to help Haleigh’s classmates have what they need for school.

 

As to the general mood of the family, I have to admire Crystal, Marie and the rest of their family for their strength and positivity.  The event was similar to a family picnic, complete with friends stopping by to visit, fried chicken, children playing, cupcakes, some smiles, some tears and a great deal of love.  That this family can find something to smile and even laugh about is a testament to their resilience.  In spite of the obvious pain and the numerous questions, they remain positive that this case will be resolved in God’s time and they are confident that justice will be served.

 

Saturday is a day I will never forget.  Crystal, Marie, and their family & friends are people I will never forget.  

 

I must add that contrary to rumors being perpetrated on the internet, the family did not sell anything at the Haleigh’s Closet event.  T shirts with Haleigh’s face were worn by everyone who spent the day at the event,  however they were not offered for sale.  Nor were cash donations solicited at all throughout the day.

 

Catching Up

Filed under: Uncategorized — justiceforhaleigh @ 12:09 pm

After taking a few days off,  there are several new items to report.   I will be making separate posts on various topics over the next day or two.  Let me say that the movement we have seen this week shows me that law enforcement is paying attention.  I am pleased about that.

I have updates planned on the following;

An attendee at Haleigh’s Closet has written about  his experiences at Riverfront Park on Saturday so I can share them here.

Press Release from the PCSO essentially clearing Crystal and Ron while turning up the heat on Misty.

Press conference with TES and NeJame. 

Recent media appearances.

 

I cannot conclude this post without sharing the sad news that one of my favorite people passed away last week.  Reverend Vicki Hall, who contributed an article last month died last Tuesday, August 11.   Vicki was a beloved internet presence and a tremendous advocate for Justice for Haleigh.  I’m sure Vicki is working hard from the afterworld to make sure justice is served.

I will miss you, friend.